Study
|
Reason for exclusion
|
| ALBERT 1991 |
COMPARES KNEE WITH HIP |
| ALEXANDER 2002 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| ALLEN 1986 |
COMPARES TKR TO FEM-POP BYPASS |
| ANDERSON 1991 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| ASHBURN 1992 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| ASHBURN 1993 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| BACHMANN 1997 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| BANNWARTH 1993 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| BASSO 1987 |
NOT RCT |
| BEARDSWORTH 1989 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| BEATTIE 1997 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS, ANALGESIC DATA REPORTED IN ETCHES 1995 |
| BIANCONI 2003 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| BOGOCH 2002 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| BOURNE 1995 |
NO SEPARATE PAIN SCORE |
| BRUNSCHWILER 1998 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| BREIT 2004 |
PAIN SCORE DATA NOT ANALYSED |
| CAPDEVILA 1999 |
COMBINED TKR AND ARTHROLYSIS |
| CHELLY 2001 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| COLWELL 1992 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| COOK 2003 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| COOPER 1993 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| DAHLSTEDT 1990 |
LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTION. NO PAIN SCORES |
| DALTROY 1998 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| DALURY 1999 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| DE ANDRES 1999 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| DE BEER 2005 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| DIAZ-BORJON 2004 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| DODD 1990 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| DRAKEFORD 1991 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| ELEDJAM 2002 |
MAJOR OPEN KNEE SURGERY |
| ETCHES 1995 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| FAURE 1993 |
NO PAIN SCORES, NOT RCT |
| FELLER 1996 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| FERNANDEZ-GALINSKI 2005 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| FLORY 2001 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| FORST 1999 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| FRAGEN 1995 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| GANAPATHY 1997 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| GAO 1995 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| GEHRIG 2005 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| GILDONE 2005 |
NO VAS PAIN SCORES |
| GIUFFRE 1991 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| GOODCHILD 2001 |
KNEE RECONSTRUCTIVE SURGERY |
| GREENGRASS 1998 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| HASHIMOTO 2003 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| HAUG 1988 |
NOT RCT, NO PAIN SCORES |
| HEAVNER 2003 |
NON-EMERGENCY SURGERY (COMBINED DATA) |
| HECHT 1983 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| HERRICK 1996 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| HOLMSTRÖM 1993 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| HOMMERIL 1994 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| ILAHI 1994 |
NOT RCT |
| ISAAC 2005 |
NOT RANDOMISED PROPERLY |
| JACOBSON 1988 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| JACOBSON 1990 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| JARIT 2003 |
COMBINED KNEE SURGERIES |
| JARSKI 2000 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| JOCHUM 2004 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| KAJINO 1997 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| KEATING 1999 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| KERRICK 1993 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| KILICKAN 2000 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| KIM 2001 |
NOT RCT |
| KOPACZ 1999 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| KOSTAMOVAARA 1996 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| KRAMER 2003 |
NO PAIN SCORE COMPARISON BETWEEN GROUPS |
| LASKIN 2000 |
PAIN SCORES NOT ANALYSED FROM RANDOMISED GROUPS – MATCH PAIRED |
| LAU 1998 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| LEVAI 1983 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| LICCIARDONE 2004 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| LOMBARDI 2004 |
NOT RCT – RETROSPECTIVE STUDY |
| LOVE 1996 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS (+ GYNECOLOGICAL SURGERY) |
| MACDONALD 2000 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| MAHONEY 1990 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION – GROUPS RUN SEQUENTIALLY) |
| MANNION 2005 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| MANNION 2005 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| MARTENS 1991 |
NO SUBGROUP ANALYSIS: TKR, LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTION, TIBIAL OSTEOTOMIES |
| MASRI 1996 |
NOT PROPERLY RANDOMISED |
| MCCASKIE 1998 |
NOT PROPERLY RANDOMISED |
| MISRA 1991 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| MISRA 2003 |
NO SEPARATE PAIN SCORE |
| MORSI 2002 |
NOT RCT |
| MURDOCH 2002 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| NAVAS 2005 |
REVIEW ARTICLE |
| NELISSEN 1998 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| NENDICK 2000 |
NOT PROPERLY RANDOMISED – BY HOSPITAL NO. |
| NEWMAN 1998 |
NO SEPARATE PAIN SCORES |
| NEWMAN 2000 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| NIELSEN 1988 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| NIELSEN 1990 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| NIEMI 1996 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| NIZARD 2005 |
META-ANALYSIS |
| ONG 2003 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| OZKOCAK 2004 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| PANG 1999 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| PELLINO 2005 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| PENG 2003 |
NOT RCT |
| PUOLAKKA 2000 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| RAJ 1987 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| RASMUSSEN 2005 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| RATHMELL 2003 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| REAY 1989 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| REDHA 2005 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| REITER 2003 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| REUBEN 1999 |
ACL SURGERY |
| REUBEN 2002 |
PRE-OPERATIVE PAIN SCORES (NOT POST) |
| RISBERG 1999 |
LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTION. NO PAIN SCORES |
| RITTER 1988 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| RITTER 1989 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| ROBISON 1991 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| ROSSELAND 1999 |
DIAGNOSTIC/THERAPEUTIC KNEE ARTHROSCOPY |
| SCHNEIDER 1998 |
KNEE SOCIETY SCORE, NO SEPARATE PAIN SCORES |
| SHOJI 1989 |
NOT RCT |
| SKINNER 2004 |
NOT RCT – RETROSPECTIVE STUDY |
| STANDL 2001 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| STEWART 2005 |
ACL RECONSTRUCTION. |
| TARRADELL 1996 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| TETER 1990 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| THOMPSON 2001 |
NOT A COMPARATIVE STUDY |
| TIMLIN 2003 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| TOKOZOGLU 1998 |
NOT RCT |
| TSUEDA 1998 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| TURNER 1996 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| WAIKAKUL 2000 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| WALKER 1991 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| WARD 2002 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| WASILEWSKI 1990 |
NOT RCT (NO RANDOMISATION) |
| WEIDENHIELM 1993 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| WHITE 1992 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| WILDER-SMITH 1994 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| WILLIAMS-RUSSO 1996 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| WONG 1996 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |
| WORLAND 1997 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| ZENIOS 2002 |
NO PAIN SCORES |
| ZHOU 2001 |
COMBINED KNEE AND HIP SURGERY GROUPS |